EU acts to defend voting rights of expats in Italy
British and Irish expats in Italy who want to hold on to the right to vote in their home countries were finally handed a boost by the European Commission on Wednesday. But will it change anything?
Expats living in other European countries should be given the right to vote in general elections – even if they’ve been abroad for years – the European Commission has said.
Viviane Reding, the EU’s justice commissioner, said citizens of the UK, Ireland, Denmark, Cyprus and Malta were effectively being “punished” and rendered “second-class citizens” for moving to other European countries – something they have the right to do under EU treaties.
Under current rules, British citizens lose the vote if they have lived outside the UK for 15 years. The other four countries restrict voting rights in other ways.
“The right to vote is one of the fundamental political rights of citizenship. It is part of the very fabric of democracy,” Reding said.
Harry Shindler has been living in Italy for nearly 30 years, and for the last 12 has been fighting reclaim his voter rights. READ MORE HERE: 'We will win like the Suffragettes'
Citizens of EU member states living elsewhere in the 28-member bloc automatically have the right to vote in local and European Parliament elections, but rules for voting in national elections and referendums are decided by individual states.
Admitting she could not force countries to change their rules, Reding said countries should allow citizens to participate in national votes if they could demonstrate a continuing interest in the political life of their country. One suggestion is that they could demonstrate this interest by applying to remain on the electoral roll.
In a recent Eurobarometer poll on electoral rights, two thirds of respondents said it was unfair that people lost their vote when they moved abroad within the EU.
The issue has been the subject of a campaign by British expats in various parts of the EU. Harry Shindler, who lives in Italy, last year lost his fight to have the restrictions overturned in the European Court of Human Rights. He likened his struggle to that of the Suffragettes.
Brian Cave, who lives in France, recently explained his position in an article for The Local France.
“Culturally I am British. I am very interested in how Britain acts in the world and who it decides to go to war with. I am tied up with Britain in every way and therefore should have the right to vote.
“The British government acts in my name but I don’t have a say in who it is."
Citizens of other European countries keep their vote under certain conditions. Germany requires citizens to be familiar with and affected by national politics. Austria requires voters to periodically renew their registration on the electoral roll.
British ministers have expressed qualified support for an extension of the franchise – Constitutional Reform Minister Mark Harper said in 2011 that the government was “considering” calls for change.
As yet, though, no concrete moves have been made.
While the most vocal campaigners want people to keep the vote in their home countries, others such as the Let Me Vote campaign say European citizens should be able to vote in the country in which they live.
Jean-Christophe Lagarde, secretary general of the French centre-right party the UDI told The Local France: “It makes much more sense to vote in the country where you live, than where you are from. If I lived in Germany I would want to have the vote for the Bundestag elections.”
Click here to sign a petition calling for the creation of MPs for expats.
Don't miss a story about Italy - Join us on Facebook and Twitter.
Comments
See Also
Expats living in other European countries should be given the right to vote in general elections – even if they’ve been abroad for years – the European Commission has said.
Viviane Reding, the EU’s justice commissioner, said citizens of the UK, Ireland, Denmark, Cyprus and Malta were effectively being “punished” and rendered “second-class citizens” for moving to other European countries – something they have the right to do under EU treaties.
Under current rules, British citizens lose the vote if they have lived outside the UK for 15 years. The other four countries restrict voting rights in other ways.
“The right to vote is one of the fundamental political rights of citizenship. It is part of the very fabric of democracy,” Reding said.
Harry Shindler has been living in Italy for nearly 30 years, and for the last 12 has been fighting reclaim his voter rights. READ MORE HERE: 'We will win like the Suffragettes'
Citizens of EU member states living elsewhere in the 28-member bloc automatically have the right to vote in local and European Parliament elections, but rules for voting in national elections and referendums are decided by individual states.
Admitting she could not force countries to change their rules, Reding said countries should allow citizens to participate in national votes if they could demonstrate a continuing interest in the political life of their country. One suggestion is that they could demonstrate this interest by applying to remain on the electoral roll.
In a recent Eurobarometer poll on electoral rights, two thirds of respondents said it was unfair that people lost their vote when they moved abroad within the EU.
The issue has been the subject of a campaign by British expats in various parts of the EU. Harry Shindler, who lives in Italy, last year lost his fight to have the restrictions overturned in the European Court of Human Rights. He likened his struggle to that of the Suffragettes.
Brian Cave, who lives in France, recently explained his position in an article for The Local France.
“Culturally I am British. I am very interested in how Britain acts in the world and who it decides to go to war with. I am tied up with Britain in every way and therefore should have the right to vote.
“The British government acts in my name but I don’t have a say in who it is."
Citizens of other European countries keep their vote under certain conditions. Germany requires citizens to be familiar with and affected by national politics. Austria requires voters to periodically renew their registration on the electoral roll.
British ministers have expressed qualified support for an extension of the franchise – Constitutional Reform Minister Mark Harper said in 2011 that the government was “considering” calls for change.
As yet, though, no concrete moves have been made.
While the most vocal campaigners want people to keep the vote in their home countries, others such as the Let Me Vote campaign say European citizens should be able to vote in the country in which they live.
Jean-Christophe Lagarde, secretary general of the French centre-right party the UDI told The Local France: “It makes much more sense to vote in the country where you live, than where you are from. If I lived in Germany I would want to have the vote for the Bundestag elections.”
Click here to sign a petition calling for the creation of MPs for expats.
Don't miss a story about Italy - Join us on Facebook and Twitter.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.