• Italy's news in English
 

Fake painting unearthed at Venice's Guggenheim

AFP · 7 Feb 2014, 08:53

Published: 07 Feb 2014 08:53 GMT+01:00

The art world's top experts and researchers have been trying to establish since the 1970s whether a painting believed to be part of the "Contraste de Formes" series produced by French artist Fernand Leger between 1913 and 1914 was genuine.

The Guggenheim Collection kept the painting in storage while Leger expert Douglas Cooper - who suspected it may be a fake - tried along with others to certify its origin, without success.

Scientists at the Florence-based Institute for Nuclear Physicists triumphed with a brand new carbon 14 dating method, the so-called "bomb peak" curve, never before used in the art world.

"It is now a certainty that the painting is a fake. The enigma has now been solved," the institute said in a statement.

"The researchers measured the radiocarbon content in a minute fragment of unpainted canvas of the work, believed to be part of the Contraste de Formes series... then plotted their results against the so-called 'bomb peak' curve," it said.

"This comparison, used for the first time to ascertain the authenticity of a painting, demonstrated with absolute certainty that the canvas support was produced after 1959, at least four years later than Leger's death in 1955," it added.

The "bomb peak" is based on radiocarbon levels released during a series of nuclear tests conducted during the Cold War, after 1955.

One of the secondary effects of these was an enormous increase in the level of radiocarbon (C-14) in the earth's atmosphere, the institute said.

These levels peaked towards the mid-sixties and then fell again with the signing of various international treaties banning nuclear weapons tests.

"Scientists call this phenomenon the 'bomb peak'. As the level of radiocarbon in the atmosphere increased, it also increased at a corresponding
rate in all living organisms, including the cotton and linen plants used to make canvases for artwork," it said.

The Guggenheim Collection sent a small sample from a folded, unpainted edge of the canvas of the painting and sent it to Florence where it was analysed using accelerator mass spectrometry.

Story continues below…

Physicists measured the level of radiocarbon to establish the date of the canvas - based on when the crops used to make the canvas were harvested - by comparing the level of radiocarbon in the fabric with those over the bomb peak period.

The results of the analysis - which revealed a much higher radiocarbon content than there would have been had the work been an original - were
published in The European Physical Journal Plus on January 21st.

Pier Andrea Mando, head of the institute's Florence division, said it was "the first time radiocarbon dating has been used to reveal a forgery in
contemporary art, by comparing levels of that isotope in the atmosphere during the bomb peak period."

Don't miss a story about Italy - Join us on Facebook and Twitter.

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Mosques tackle home-grown terror with Italian sermons
Sermons at Friday prayers will now be delivered in Italian in Florence mosques. Photo: Santiago Almada

Mosques tackle home-grown terror with Italian sermons
39 minutes ago

Florence is the first city to roll the initiative out as part of plans to integrate Muslims into Italian society.

Six migrant smugglers sentenced to jail in Italy first
Ex-EU President Jose Manuel Barroso (3rd R), Italy's ex-PM Enrico Letta (R) and ex-EU Home Affairs Commissionner Cecilia Malmström (L) stand by victims' coffins in Oct 2013. Photo: Robeto Solomone/AFP

Six migrant smugglers sentenced to jail in Italy first
1 hour ago

The convictions were in connection to the Lampedusa shipwreck in 2013.

Italy anger mounts over Cairo student's torturous death
Italian student Giulio Regeni was murderd in Cairo last week. Photo: Mohamed El-Shahed/AFP

Italy anger mounts over Cairo student's torturous death
1 hour ago

Evidence points to the Egyptian security services as the student's most likely killer.

Raffaele Sollecito creates a social network for the dead
Raffaele Sollecito spent four years in prison for the murder of Meredith Kercher before being acquittted last year. Photo: Fillipo Monteforte / AFP

Raffaele Sollecito creates a social network for the dead
3 hours ago

Raffaele Sollecito, who along with Amanda Knox was acquitted of murdering Meredith Kercher, talks to The Local about his unusual new venture.

Three sentenced for up to 16 years for Milan machete attack
The attack happened last June at Milan's Villapizzone station. Screengrab: Corriere TV

Three sentenced for up to 16 years for Milan machete attack
4 hours ago

A train conductor almost lost his arm in the brutal attack.

Video
Seventy hurt by flying oranges in Italy's crazy fruit fight
Ivrea's traditional 'Battle of the Oranges'. Photo: Marco Bertorello/AFP

Seventy hurt by flying oranges in Italy's crazy fruit fight
6 hours ago

But that's fewer than last year...

Fans fulfil mask pledge to racism victim Koulibaly
People hold flyers depicting the face of Napoli's French defender Kalidou Koulibaly in solidarity with the player, who suffered racist abuse last week. Photo: Carlo Hermann/AFP

Fans fulfil mask pledge to racism victim Koulibaly
8 hours ago

Lazio were later handed a €50,000 fine over the racist chants.

‘Spare no effort’ to resolve Syrian crisis, says pope
“I appeal to the international community to spare no effort to urgently bring parties back to the negotiating table,” the pontiff said. Photo: Tiziana Fabi/AFP

‘Spare no effort’ to resolve Syrian crisis, says pope
1 day ago

Pope Francis on Sunday urged the world community to make every effort to revive the Syrian peace talks and appealed for unstinting generosity for civilians fleeing the conflict.

Former victim leaves Vatican child sex abuse commission
St Peter's Basilica, at the Vatican. Photo: Alberto PIzzoli/AFP

Former victim leaves Vatican child sex abuse commission
1 day ago

A former paedophilia victim has left the Vatican advisory commission on sexual abuse by the clergy, the Vatican announced Saturday, two days after the British campaigner criticized the body in the press.

Four probed after Italian actor hanged during live show
Four people are being investigated after an actor was hanged during a live show. Photo: Facebook

Four probed after Italian actor hanged during live show
3 days ago

The young actor, who was hanged during a theatre performance last weekend, was declared clinically brain dead on Thursday.

Sponsored Article
US taxes and FATCA: 'The time for hiding is over'
How Under the Tuscan Sun changed a small Italian town
National
Ten things to do in Italy in February
Ten fantastic holidays for Italy-loving foodies
5,000 migrant kids vanished in Italy: but where are they?
National
What you need to know about Italy's new smoking laws
Politics
Why Italy's scrapping to be let into Europe's big boys' club
International
US museum gives Italy back looted head of Greek statue
National
Why Italy has no choice but to pass gay civil unions bill
National
Rome's nude statues covered to spare Rouhani's blushes
National
Thousands march in Italy for gay rights
National
Meet Dante Alighieri's stargazing Italian descendant
National
Why are tourists turning away from Rome?
Culture
Ten wonderfully quirky Italian animal-related idioms
Society
Italy chills out over medical cannabis cultivators
National
Italy gay unions face defeat as left-wing Catholics rebel
National
Bronze Age village found near ancient Roman city
Health
Probe sheds light on Italy childbirth deaths
International
Europe's open border policy not working: Italy
Culture
Italians petition God to 'bring back David Bowie'
Sport
Italian female footballers defy mafia-style threats
Politics
Italy halts plan to stop fining illegal migrants
3,238
jobs available