Italy’s C-section rate among Europe’s highest

Italy has the second highest caesarean delivery rate in Europe, mainly because doctors perceive the procedure to be safer as it allows them to mitigate problems that may arise during natural childbirth, the co-author of a report published on Monday told The Local.

Italy's C-section rate among Europe's highest
Italy has the second highest rate of C-section deliveries in Europe. Photo: C-section photo: Shutterstock

The report by the International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecologists (BJOG) found that 38 percent of births in Italy are carried out through caesarean section.

Cyprus has the highest rate (52 percent) while Switzerland and Germany come third and fourth with 33.1 percent and 31.3 percent, respectively.

Iceland has the lowest rate (14.8 percent), followed by Finland (16.8 percent) and The Netherlands (17 percent).

Marina Cuttini, a co-author of the report and researcher at Rome’s Bambino Gesù Children's Hospital, said most caesareans are suggested by doctors towards the end of a pregnancy in order to avoid complications and the risk of being sued if anything goes wrong.

Doctors also prefer this option as they are able to better plan the delivery date and care around the birth.

Women who gave birth to their first child through caeserean section are also more likely to be advised to repeat the procedure for the second and subsequent births.

Meanwhile, women also ask for a caesarean in order to be able to schedule when their child will be born as well as to avoid the pain of a natural birth.

“But the abdominal surgery involved with a caeserean is also painful," Cuttini told The Local, adding that demand from women depends on how information on the options for childbirth is transmitted.

Italy also has the highest number in Europe of mothers giving birth to their first child over the age of 35, which plays a role in doctors’ recommending caesereans as it is deemed safer than a natural birth for older women.

Private clinics tend to perform more caesereans than public hospitals, with the financial reward being an incentive, Cuttini added.

But although the rate of caesarean deliveries grew steadily since the 1980s, it has stabilized in recent years thanks to government intervention, she added.

“There was action at government-level, such as issuing guidelines, in response to our last report in 2008. We are happy now that the rate is stable.”

The rate of caesarean deliveries has been rising around the world for years, Cuttini said, adding that many are done unnecessarily, putting women and babies through the risks of a major operation.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Pope appoints French woman to senior synod post

Pope Francis has broken with Catholic tradition to appoint a woman as an undersecretary of the synod of bishops, the first to hold the post with voting rights in a body that studies major questions of doctrine.

Pope appoints French woman to senior synod post
Pope Francis has appointed Nathalie Becquart as undersecretary of the synod of bishops. She is the first woman to hold the post. Photo: AFP

Frenchwoman Nathalie Becquart is one of the two new undersecretaries named on Saturday to the synod, where she has been a consultant since 2019.

The appointment signals the pontiff's desire “for a greater participation of women in the process of discernment and decision-making in the church”, said Cardinal Mario Grech, the secretary-general of the synod.

“During the previous synods, the number of women participating as experts and listeners has increased,” he said.

“With the nomination of Sister Nathalie Becquart and her possibility of participating in voting, a door has opened.”

The synod is led by bishops and cardinals who have voting rights and also comprises experts who cannot vote, with the next gathering scheduled for autumn 2022.

A special synod on the Amazon in 2019 saw 35 female “auditors” invited to the assembly, but none could vote.

The Argentinian-born pope has signalled his wish to reform the synod and have women and laypeople play a greater role in the church.

He named Spaniard Luis Marin de San Martin as the other under undersecretary in the synod of bishops.

Becquart, 52, a member of the France-based Xaviere Sisters, has a master's degree in management from the prestigious HEC business school in Paris and studied in Boston before joining the order.