Press freedom ‘at stake’ as Vatileaks verdict expected

A Vatican drama of sex, lies and press freedom was to peak on Thursday with a verdict in the trial of two journalists and sources accused of leaking details about financial mismanagement within the Holy See.

Press freedom 'at stake' as Vatileaks verdict expected
PR expert Francesca Chaouqui and Spanish monsignor Lucio Vallejo Balda turned on each other in the witness box. Photo: Umberto Pizzi/AFP

Italian investigative journalist Emiliano Fittipaldi, on trial with colleague Gianluigi Nuzzi after publishing books based on secret Vatican papers, told the press the judges had retired to deliberate and a verdict was
expected at 4:00 pm (1400 GMT).

Three other people – a Spanish Vatican official, his assistant and an Italian communications consultant – have joined them in the dock since November.

The scandal, the second to hit the Vatican, rocked the Roman Catholic Church with its leaked accounts of theft and greed, along with publication of secret recordings of Pope Francis's private conversations.

It then ballooned into steamier fare, as Spanish monsignor Lucio Vallejo Balda and PR expert Francesca Chaouqui turned on each other in the witness box.

Details emerged of alleged sexual affairs, glitzy parties and secret plots in the corridors of power.

Chaouqui, who had been involved in a review of Vatican finances and is accused of both “inspiring” and being ultimately responsibility for the leaks, was the only one to address the court Thursday.

The prosecution has called for a sentence of three years and nine months for Chaouqui, who along with the three other Italian nationals may be subject to an extradition request from the Vatican state in the case of a guilty verdict.

Chaouqui, who gave birth three weeks ago, said Thursday she feared the Vatican would ask Italy to clap her behind bars.

“If the court asks Italy to carry out the sentence, my son and I will spend the first years of his life behind bars,” she told the court.

Press freedom

Fighting to hold back tears, she apologised to the judges for her someone erratic behaviour during the trial, but also complained about the prosecution's bid to give her the heaviest prison sentence, saying it was “as if I had acted alone”.

Vallejo Balda admitted to leaking the classified papers but said he had done so under pressure from Chaouqui, with whom he claimed to have a “compromising” relationship. The PR consultant had allegedly threatened to “destroy” him.

He also claimed he had been blackmailed by a woman he believed to have links to Italian secret services and other contacts in a “dangerous world”.

The trial has provoked outrage among campaigners for press freedom.

In closing statements on Wednesday, prosecutors rebutted accusations that the tiny city-state was attacking the media's freedom. Earlier this week they called for Nuzzi to be handed a one-year suspended sentence.

But Nuzzi's defence team insisted the journalist was merely “an Italian citizen who exercised the freedom of the press on Italian soil without endangering the peace and security of the Vatican”.

Fittipaldi, who prosecutors said should be acquitted due to a lack of evidence, also defended his “right to inform” the public.

All five accused have been prosecuted under draconian anti-leaks legislation, which could have seen them face prison terms of between four and eight years.

The law was rushed onto the Vatican statute book in 2013 as a result of the fallout from the first Vatileaks scandal, which centred on secrets divulged by the butler of now-retired Pope Benedict XVI.

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Book details alleged sexual abuse in the Vatican

An Italian journalist acquitted in last year's so-called Vatileaks trial published on Thursday a book detailing the attempts of a young whistleblower to report alleged sexual abuse.

Book details alleged sexual abuse in the Vatican
Gianluigi Nuzzi reveals new confidential documents in his latest book "Original Sin". Photo: Gabriel Bouys/AFP

Gianluigi Nuzzi reveals new confidential documents in his latest book “Original Sin”, which documents the inner workings of the Vatican and touches on some of the scandals or conspiracies that dog it.

Nuzzi last year stood trial in front of Vatican judges accused of publishing stolen papers but was acquitted after they considered he had not committed a crime on Vatican territory.

His fourth book claims an adult seminarian sexually abused a high school student aged 17 to 18 in 2011-2012.

Kamil Tadeusz Jazembowski, from Poland, said he witnessed the abuse of his roomate while living in the Vatican's residence for children and young people hoping to become priests.

He claims a seminarian who had been allowed to live in the housing facility repeatedly visited his roommate at night and that the youngster “felt obliged to go along with it”.

He says he was forced to leave the residence after he tried to raise his concerns with Vatican authorities.

The aggressor exercised “a form of power and intimidation” over the underage students and imposed “bullying or sexual acts” on them, he tells the book, speaking with the victim's permission.

The accused seminarian recently became a priest.

“I don't blame the priests for being gay. All this is a vast hypocrisy: during the day these people are homophobic, at night they are unleashed in gay clubs,” said Jazembowski, who is also gay.

The Vatican did not say if an investigation has been opened when approached by AFP.

The book also investigates the mysterious disappearance in 1983 of Emmanuela Orlandi, the young daughter of an employee of the Vatican State.