Five Star Movement leader is a 'threat' to press freedom in Italy: Reporters Without Borders

The Local Italy
The Local Italy - [email protected]
Five Star Movement leader is a 'threat' to press freedom in Italy: Reporters Without Borders
Five Star Movement leader Beppe Grillo. Photo: AFP

Press freedom in Italy has improved significantly over the past year, Reporters Without Borders said on Wednesday. But the NGO warned journalists still face threats and intimidation from politicians as well as criminal groups.


Italy's ranking in the organization's Press Freedom Index leapt 25 places from last year, but remained just outside the top 50 at 52nd place worldwide.

The rise bucked a global trend of worsening press freedom, with almost two thirds of countries seeing a drop in their score, as the NGO warned: "Media freedom is under threat now more than ever."

But Italy remained one of the lowest-ranked countries in Western Europe, with press freedom a "noticeable problem", according to the rankings.

Reporters Without Borders noted that Italy "continues to be one of the European countries where the most journalists are threatened by organized crime". 

Six Italian journalists are under 24-hour police protection due to death threats from organized crime groups, most famously Roberto Saviano, whose book Gomorrah examined the grip of the Camorra mafia group on Naples.

READ ALSO: Gomorrah writer Saviano tells mafia: 'You did not succeed'

Reporters working in the south of the country or its capital are particularly exposed to pressure from mafia and other criminal groups, Reporters Without Borders said.

But threats to Italian press freedom also come from politicians, with the NGO saying journalists "increasingly opt to censor themselves" due to pressure from politicians. A recent law made defaming politicians, judges, or civil servants punishable by sentences of six to nine years in prison.

The writers of the report singled out Beppe Grillo, the leader of the Five Star Movement, for publicly 'outing' journalists he dislikes.

Grillo has eschewed Italy's mainstream media, preferring to post on his blog than answer questions from journalists, but the report linked his criticism of specific journalists to an "alarming" rise in violence against journalists.

However, Italy's overall score in the rankings did improve, with its significant rise partly due to the acquittal of several journalists in defamation cases, including two who were tried in the Vatileaks 2 case.

In 2014, Italy reached 49th place in the rankings, before tumbling to 73rd in 2015 due to a surge of attacks, many mafia-linked, and sinking even further to 77th place last year.

The World Press Freedom Index is published annually, ranking 180 countries with scores calculated by a questionnaire of international experts, supported by a qualitative analysis.

Norway took the top spot in the most recent rankings, followed by Nordic neighbour Sweden, while Eritrea (ranked 179th) lost its last place ranking to North Korea for the first time in a decade.

READ ALSO: Italy's populist leader: Public should decide whether news is fakeItaly's populist leader: Public should decide whether news is fake
Photo: Marco Bertorello/AFP



Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

See Also