Italy's northern regions are challenging a mandatory vaccine law

Catherine Edwards
Catherine Edwards - [email protected]
Italy's northern regions are challenging a mandatory vaccine law
Veneto's regional governor Luca Zaia, pictured during a press conference. File photo: Alberto Pizzoli/AFP

Several regions in northern Italy are challenging a recently passed law which made 12 vaccinations mandatory for children starting at state school.


Italy's cabinet approved the vaccine law in mid-May, making it compulsory for all school starters to have a set of 12 vaccinations. 

But in Veneto, the regional government said on Tuesday that its lawyers were preparing to challenge the decree in Italy's Constitutional Court, and that the legal challenge would be ready in around two weeks.

"Let's be clear; we are not against vaccines; we are against making them obligatory," explained regional governor Luca Zaia, who belongs to the Northern League. 


"Here, coverage was at 92.4 percent in 2016, thanks to information given to families at every level. No to sanctions, yes to informed decisions by mums and dads!"

Zaia wrote that it had been a "mistake to ignore the regions" in passing the legislation.

However, he appeared to acknowledge that fake news surrounding the efficacy and safety of vaccines had been an issue in Italy. "Fake news should be fought through science and doctors," he said.

The head of the Northern League, Matteo Salvini, praised the move in Veneto, writing: "Children's health comes before the interest of some pharmaceutical company [...] Freedom of choice works; threats and fines don't."

He also took the chance to push the party's anti-immigrant agenda, adding: "PS. Who vaccinates the illegal immigrants?"

OPINION: 'Italy's mandatory vaccine law should be adopted worldwide'Photo: Esben Klinker/Depositphotos

Meanwhile, Liguria's regional vice-president and health councillor Sonia Viale said that the region would ask the government to amend the decree at the Conference of the Regions.

In particular, the Northern League politician wants the government to remove the clauses which mean parents who fail to get their child the necessary vaccines face fines, and the prospect of their child not being accepted into a state school.

"I say no to the imposition of vaccines when it impedes on parental rights," said Viale, according to Liguria Notizie.

And in Bolzano - a region where vaccination coverage is particularly low - there have been protests since the decree was passed. Around 130 families wrote to Italian President Sergio Mattarella to say they would "seek asylum" in Austria in order to avoid the mandatory vaccines, which they said infringed upon their human rights.

The regional council unanimously passed a motion calling for an end to "coercive measures" in favour of an awareness campaign

OPINION: 'Italy's mandatory vaccine law should be adopted worldwide'Italy makes vaccines compulsory for school starters
Health Minister Beatrice Lorenzin. Photo: Emanuel Dunand/AFP



Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.

Please log in to leave a comment.

See Also