Here’s what Italians living abroad think about the election

With Italy's election taking place on Sunday, The Local spoke to Italians living abroad to find out their take on the vote, and what it was like to watch the campaign from overseas.

Here's what Italians living abroad think about the election
A woman walks past election posters in Milan. Photo: Miguel Medina/AFP

Italians abroad can vote either for candidates in their home constituency, or for those standing for the overseas constituency, meaning they have slightly different options on their ballot papers compared to those living in Italy.

And while the majority of the population will head to the ballot box on Sunday March 4th, Italians send in postal votes in advance, so the people we spoke to had already made their decision.

Here's a selection of the views from the voters we spoke to. 


'We need to see what the Five Star Movement can do'

“I have trouble listening to all the promises and the lies,” said Rosamaria, an Italian-American who now lives in Germany. “Watching from here, where things function efficiently, has only furthered my belief that Italy is in bad shape.”

She cited her main concerns as the high unemployment rate, particularly among the young, high taxes for small businesses; and problems in the education system.

Italy's Five Star Movement names its ministers pre-election in a break with tradition
Five Star leader Luigi Di Maio (centre) and the party's ministerial candidates. Photo: Filippo Monteforte/AFP

In particular, Rosamaria is disillusioned by “the old school politicians”, including Silvio Berlusconi and Matteo Renzi. Renzi, she points out, promised to resign if he lost the 2015 referendum, and though he did quit his job as PM, he still leads the Democratic Party and is running for PM. Meanwhile, Berlusconi is barred from holding public office so won’t get a fifth term, but could end up as kingmaker after putting together a coalition that was leading in the final pre-election polls.

She sees the Five Star Movement, formed in 2009 and led by Luigi Di Maio, are “the alternative to the traditional parties”, she tells The Local. “We need to see what they can or will do. I don’t believe they are perfect but I do believe in their desire to change the things that are not working.”

'I just hope the outcome doesn't cripple the economy'

Tommaso Leso moved to Ghent, Belgium in 2014 after previously spending a year each in France and England. He has been following the election mainly online, using news sites as well as content shared on social media, predominantly by Italian and international journalists.

Tommaso Leso. Photo: Private

Two things he hasn't had access to while abroad, however, are personal interaction with people from different socio-cultural backgrounds, and Italian TV. “The former is something I miss – it would have helped having a more clear picture of “the real country”. The latter is something I really don't miss – the quality and average level of those shows is appalling,” he says.

Leso’s main concern is the economy. “I am desperately hoping for an outcome that does not cripple the Italian economy beyond the possibility of repair, nor destroys the remnants of a liberal democratic culture,” he says. “In my mind, this excludes almost all the parties in the political spectrum right now.”

However, he's sceptical about the grand promises made by most of the parties, which he says “mean next to nothing.”

He has voted for the Democratic Party in the Senate and Emma Bonino’s +Europa in the Chamber of Deputies, a choice he says he made through a process of exclusion.

However, Leso believes the most likely outcome is a victory for Silvio Berlusconi’s centre-right coalition, which he says could be “disastrous”, particularly due to the wide rifts in opinion between Berlusconi’s Forza Italia and the other two coalition partners.

“They don't agree on a lot of things, and the government might be short-lived or, worse, paralyzed.” 

'I get so angry about Italian politics I avoid it'

Veruska Anconitano, an Italian journalist and blogger in Ireland, says that none of the candidates standing for office appealed to her, so she has chosen not to vote in the election.

Although Italy has traditionally had a high turnout in national elections, regional and local votes over recent years have seen a dwindling turnout as more and more Italians grow frustrated with all sides and opt to vote with their feet.

What to expect after the Italian election: a look at the possible outcomes
A woman looks at the board bearing the parties' logos. Photo: Filippo Monteforte/AFP

This year, the turnout is expected to be down on the 2013 election.

Anconitano says she has avoided media coverage of the election: “Every time I read something, I get so annoyed and angry I prefer to avoid it. I live abroad out of choice, and I want to vote in the country where I live and where I pay taxes.”

'I care about employment, Europe, and immigration'

“The most important themes in the election for me are the question of work, the relationship with Europe, and management of immigration,” says Silvano Garnerone, who has lived in Stockholm for ten years.

He has voted for the centre-left coalition led by the Democratic Party. 

“I made by decision by choosing what I believe to be the programme and the people that best balance the political desires and the obligations of history and geopolitics,” Garnerone said.

'None of the parties match my ideas'

Antonio Consoli, an Italian who has lived in North and South America, the UK, and Sweden, tells The Local: “Living abroad opens your eyes on reality. It makes you love some things more while it decreases your tolerance for other things that you were more likely to accept back home.”

In particular, he says his tolerance for bureaucracy has decreased, though he argues that the Italian healthcare system is of a higher quality than in most other advanced economies.

He didn't want to share who he had voted for, saying “the decision was not an easy one, as none of the parties are a good match with my ideas. But I have checked carefully the profile of the people that I voted for.”

Antonio pictured in Stockholm. Photo: Private

However, the 43-year-old criticizes the “sensationalism” of the campaign, and wishes there had been more measurable targets and ambitions focused on how each party would tackle problems such as corruption and rising unemployment among young people and in the south.

“The country must strive to develop an industrial economy in the less developed southern areas. I remember Catania Industrial area, 20 years ago, was flourishing with many tech startups that were born around a university and a few multinational companies, such as Nokia and ST. Catania was called “Etna valley”. Today that area looks more like an industrial desert,” he says.

“Companies left for more convenient areas and there is little interest to invest there for many reasons (lack of infrastructure, lack of security, lack of skilled resources, no favorable taxation to compensate the required investments …). Catania is an example of what the South of Italy was and could become. Only the promise that education can land you a job can give an opportunity to children that are in school today.”

HAVE YOUR SAY: What do you think about the Italian election? Get in touch at [email protected] or via our Facebook or Twitter pages. We'll include some of your opinions in our live blog of the election on Sunday.




On eve of election, Italy braces for potential far-right win

Italians on Saturday braced for seismic change, on the eve of an election forecast to hand Italy the most right-wing government since World War II.

On eve of election, Italy braces for potential far-right win

Out with internationally respected Mario Draghi and in — polls say — with Eurosceptic Giorgia Meloni, head of the post-fascist Brothers of Italy party, who is widely tipped to become the country’s first woman to head a government.

“The country is eager for a change, a new face,” Wolfango Piccoli of the London-based political risk consultancy Teneo told AFP.

Italy is battling a series of crises, from rampant inflation and extreme weather events linked to climate change, to an energy crisis aggravated by the war in Ukraine.

READ ALSO: Political cheat sheet: Understanding the Brothers of Italy

The campaign, sparked by Draghi’s downfall in July, wrapped up on Friday, giving Italians a day of reprieve as electioneering is banned until the vote.

People who spoke to AFP in Rome on Saturday said they were unsure the day before the election as the latest polls show that the Brothers of Italy party is likely to win and form a government.

“I am worried by the fact that the polls have the right-wing as the winner, especially Giorgia Meloni,” said Maria Tasca, a 27-year-old student originally from Sicily.

‘No magic solution’

“From what she has said on women’s rights, on young people’s rights, on rights in general, I see things going backwards by at least 50 years,” Tasca added.

“The problems are worldwide, there’s no magic solution. But sometimes you have to change,” said a 75-year-old shop owner, who gave his name only as Dante.

Meloni, 45, has worked hard over the past few weeks to reassure skittish investors and an anxious Brussels that her party’s historic ties to supporters of dictator Benito Mussolini are a thing of the past.

She has softened her tone and posted a video of herself on TikTok making traditional pastries from the Puglia region.

But she channelled warrior Aragorn from Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings on Thursday at the closing rally for the right-wing coalition, which unites her Brothers of Italy with Matteo Salvini’s anti-immigration League party and billionaire Silvio Berlusconi’s Forza Italia.

READ ALSO: Political cheat sheet: Understanding Italy’s League

The self-described “Christian mother” segued smoothly from the fantasy king to blaming the left for the country’s “drug dealers, thieves, rapists and mafia”, adding: “This Italy ends on Sunday”.

Berlusconi, 85, was at her side.

The media mogul — who is on trial accused of bribing starlets not to testify about his allegedly erotic parties — has campaigned mainly online, wooing grandmothers and housewives with promises of stay-at-home salaries.

TikTok jokes

He has also chased the youth vote with some TikTok jokes — including one about not trying to steal their girlfriends.

The race has seen the parties try to win over voters with ideas such as sending goods from northern to southern Italy via tube and fighting climate change with cannabis.

READ ALSO: Political cheat sheet: Understanding Italy’s Five Star Movement

Former interior minister Salvini, 49, campaigned under the slogan “Credo” (I believe), earning him a rebuke from the Catholic Church.

Fearful of losing a significant chunk of his supporters to Meloni, Salvini has tried to stand out by calling for an end to sanctions against Russia and railing against Brussels.

But the end of his campaign was overshadowed by a video clip of him describing a blind League candidate on Thursday as “an eye for Italians”.

The centre-left’s Enrico Letta, head of the Democratic Party (PD), rocked up to his final rally in an electric van — reminding voters of his earlier efforts to promote ecologically friendly transport, when his electric campaign
bus ran out of battery.

His main rival for votes on the left, Giuseppe Conte, head of the populist Five Star Movement, seemed to have more staying power.

He was photographed so often standing head and shoulders above the crowd amid a throng of supporters that the media dubbed him the “travelling Madonna”.