Editions:  Austria · Denmark · France · Germany · Italy · Norway · Spain · Sweden · Switzerland
Advertisement

Facebook loses copyright appeal against Milan startup

Share this article

Facebook loses copyright appeal against Milan startup
Composite image showing various Facebook logos. Photo: Loic Venance/AFP
15:54 CEST+02:00
Facebook has lost its appeal against a Milan startup after a court ruled that the social media giant had copied features from an app created by the smaller company.

The ruling, made public on Monday, upheld the judgment of a preliminary court which in 2016 said Facebook had violated copyright laws and was guilty of "parasitic appropriation".

The case, which The Local reported on at the time, relates to an app called Faround, which was created by software developers Business Competence in 2012 and allows users to locate nearby shops, restaurants and other sites along with their comments and ratings on Facebook.

READ ALSO: Facebook apologizes for censoring 'sexual' Italian statue

Facebook launched its own location-finding feature, Nearby, just two months after Faround was added to the Facebook app store.

Milan's civil court of appeal has now confirmed the initial ruling, saying the two applications were identical in "concept and format" with the graphics the only significant difference between the two. Judges ordered Facebook to pay Business Competence's legal costs amounting to €1,750.

The extent of the economic damage the copyright breach caused Business Competence is yet to be clarified. Faround's creators have said the launch of Nearby led to a direct drop in download numbers and a resulting loss of earnings.

Mark Zuckerberg's company lost another case against an Italian firm in February, when Italy's Ministry of Economic Development rejected a copyright complaint from Facebook against Climbook, a website for Italy's climbing community with information and reviews of climbing routes around the world. 

The ministry said that it was "highly improbable" that users would get mixed up between the two services.

Facebook is currently embroiled in a data privacy scandal over allegations that users' personal information was shared with political consulting firm Cambridge Analytica for election purposes.

The Italian competition authority Antitrust has opened an investigation into Facebook for "alleged improper commercial practices" by not adequately informing users about data-gathering, after it emerged that as many as 200,000 Italian Facebook users may have been affected.

READ ALSO: Facebook adds fact-checking feature in Italy

 

Get notified about breaking news on The Local

Share this article

Advertisement

From our sponsors

Learn French in Switzerland: A fully immersive experience

Hiking in the Swiss Alps, visiting local chocolate factories, wine-tastings, jazz festivals and car shows are not part of your typical language course. Unless, that is, it’s an Alpadia language course.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Popular articles

Advertisement
Advertisement