‘Like a nightmare’: Family of American suspected of killing Italian policeman speak out

The mother of a US teen detained in Rome over the killing of an Italian police officer spoke on Wednesday of her shock at the arrest of her "thoughtful boy", as the suspect's father arrived in Italy.

'Like a nightmare': Family of American suspected of killing Italian policeman speak out
Tributes to murdered officer Mario Rega Cerciello at his funeral on Monday. Photo: Eliano Imperato/AFP

Finnegan Elder, 19, has been charged with aggravated homicide along with friend Gabriel Natale Hjorth, 18, following the death of officer Mario Cerciello Rega, who suffered multiple knife wounds in Friday's attack.

Elder has confessed to stabbing Cerciello, 35, with a US Marine partially serrated, close-quarters combat knife, according to police. But he says he mistook the plain-clothed officer for a dangerous drug dealer and used the weapon in self-defence.

READ ALSO: 'Terrible affair which cannot go unpunished': Italy mourns murdered police officer

Photo: Eliano Imperato/AFP

His father Ethan Elder said on arrival in Rome that “the first thing I need to know is how to get into prison to see my son,” before heading directly with his lawyer to the city's Regina Coeli jail, according to Italian media reports.

“We feel like our world has come crashing down,” Elder's mother Leah said in an interview with Italy's La Stampa daily. “I don't know how to describe it. It's like a nightmare we'll wake up from.”

Their son was high on a mix of spirits, beer and prescription medicines when the attack took place, police said on Tuesday. Cerciello had tackled him to the ground during a nighttime drugs raid in a genteel Rome neighbourhood.

READ ALSO: Stabbed 11 times: Prosecutors reveal how Italian police officer was murdered

Photo: Filippo Monteforte/AFP

“Finn is a thoughtful boy. The only explanation I can give, if he really is involved directly in this tragedy, is that he was terrified and therefore reacted rashly,” the suspect's mother said.

'Fight night'

She added that he had in the past taken powerful painkillers for an injury to his hand suffered while working part-time in a car parts shop. He had to have part of a finger amputated after a nasty fall off a ladder which left his left hand partially paralysed, she said.

The teenager took “strong painkillers and opioids” to manage the pain, as well as marijuana, she added.

Cerciello and his plainclothes partner Varriale had been tasked with intercepting the Californian teens after an intermediary on a drug deal reported them to the police for stealing his bag after they were sold aspirin in the place of cocaine.

“I didn't know he did any other drugs,” Leah Elder said.

Carabinieri carry their colleague's coffin. Photo: Eliano Imperato/AFP

Asked about a violent incident when her son was younger, in which he punched a fellow teenager who fell and hit his head, she said it was part of a boxing ritual called “fight night” and not a sign Finnegan was violent.

“Finn had agreed to take part in a match with a friend, the other kids were gathered around watching. He hit him and the boy fell and hit his head and was hurt badly, but recovered in a few days and is very well now,” she said.

He was ordered to perform community service and after that his criminal record was wiped clean, she added.

'Having a knife is not unusual'

The weapon used in the attack on Cerciello, which has an 18-centimetre blade, was brought over from the US.

“Having a knife is not unusual for a kid of his age in our neighbourhood,” Elder said.

The family, which has Irish, Lithuanian and Spanish roots, had sentimental ties to Italy. The Elders had been on their honeymoon in Tuscany and “we fell in love with the country”.

“When Finn said he was going to Italy too, where I used to go as a girl, we were happy,” Leah Elder said.

Blindfold photo

Meanwhile a photo of Elder's co-accused wearing a blindfold during interrogation has prompted a police probe. 

As investigators search officers' mobile phones for evidence who took the photo of Natale Hjorth bound and handcuffed in the presence of several carabinieri, the person believed to be responsible for blindfolding him has been placed under investigation for possible abuse of office, Italian media reported on Wednesday.

There are concerns that the incident could invalidate the suspect's interrogation, during which he reportedly confessed.

READ ALSO: US suspect blindfolded during questioning over Italian policeman's murder

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


New York returns millions worth of stolen art to Italy

Prosecutors in New York on Tuesday returned dozens of antiquities stolen from Italy and valued at around $19 million, some of which were found in the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

New York returns millions worth of stolen art to Italy

“These 58 pieces represent thousands of years of rich history, yet traffickers throughout Italy utilized looters to steal these items and to line their own pockets,” said Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, noting that it was the third such repatriation in nine months.

“For far too long, they have sat in museums, homes, and galleries that had no rightful claim to their ownership,” he said at a ceremony attended by Italian diplomats and law enforcement officials.

The stolen items had been sold to Michael Steinhardt, one of the world’s leading collectors of ancient art, the DA’s office said, adding that he had been slapped with a “first-of-its-kind lifetime ban on acquiring antiquities.”


Among the recovered treasures, which in some cases were sold to “unwitting collectors and museums,” were a marble head of the Greek goddess Athena from 200 B.C.E. and a drinking cup dating back to 470 B.C.E, officials said.

The pieces were stolen at the behest of four men who “all led highly lucrative criminal enterprises – often in competition with one another – where they would use local looters to raid archaeological sites throughout Italy, many of which were insufficiently guarded,” the DA’s office said.

One of them, Pasquale Camera, was “a regional crime boss who organized thefts from museums and churches as early as the 1960s. He then began purchasing stolen artifacts from local looters and sold them to antiquities dealers,” it added.

It said that this year alone, the DA’s office has “returned nearly 300 antiquities valued at over $66 million to 12 countries.”