‘Agree to our programme or go to the polls’: M5S warns Italy’s coalition deal could yet collapse

Italy's anti-establishment Five Star Movement (M5S) warned on Friday that its tentative coalition deal with the centre-left Democratic Party could still fall apart.

'Agree to our programme or go to the polls': M5S warns Italy's coalition deal could yet collapse
Luigi Di Maio, head of Italy's Five Star Movement. Photo: Filippo Monteforte/AFP

M5S chief Luigi Di Maio said “either we are in agreement on carrying through the points of our (M5S) programme, or we stop here”.

Should the Democratic Party (PD) — which was the Movement's bitter enemy until just a couple of weeks ago — not agree to the M5S's key policy demands, “it would be better to go back to the polls as soon as possible,” he said.


Di Maio's warning followed consultations with premier-designate Giuseppe Conte, who has been tasked with forming a new government following the collapse of Italy's populist coalition earlier this month.

“We're not looking at a government just to get by, we consider some of the points of our programme indispensable,” he said.

The PD's reaction was swift and sharp, with Graziano Delrio, the party's lower house leader, insisting it was “committed to loyally supporting the efforts of Prime Minister Conte. This effort alone has already restored confidence in Italy.”

“Di Maio's ultimatums to the premier designate are completely unacceptable,” he said.


Conte met with all Italy's main parties on Friday as he raced to ensure his coalition would have the necessary working majority.

Political watchers have said Di Maio, 33, is fighting for his political life after the previous M5S-League coalition saw him reduced to an extra in what essentially became hard-right interior minister Matteo Salvini's show. Di Maio has reportedly demanded he be kept on as deputy prime minister — something the PD is set against.

PROFILE: Italy's PM Conte, the 'Mr Nobody' who found his voice

Premier-designate Giuseppe Conte arrives at the Senate on Friday. Photo: Andreas Solaro/AFP

“Luigi's most bellicose advisors are entertaining the idea of pulling the rug on the deal if the negotiations for cabinet posts go badly for their chief,” Simone Canettieri wrote in the Messaggero newspaper on Friday.

Canettieri said that Di Maio was sending “clear warnings” to Conte, including his insistence that any programme accord between the M5S and PD would have to be voted on online by the Movement's members. That vote is expected to take place only once Conte has unveiled his team next week.

The M5S is flexing its muscles because it was the biggest winner in last year's general election, with more than 33 percent of the vote, while the PD came in second with nearly 19 percent.


Michiel van der Veen, an economist with RaboResearch, warned that “plenty of (M5S) voters are expected to oppose a tie-up, while Five Star also wants technocrats in important ministerial positions rather than the PD's preferred option of politicians”.

The parties are also divided on issues such as migration laws and a high-speed railway between Italy and France.

Milan's stock market sunk into the red over Friday's tensions. In the government bond market, the “spread” between Italy's bond yields and those of rock-solid Germany widened, indicating that investors were demanding a higher risk premium in return for investing in Italian sovereign debt.

READ ALSO: Four key economic challenges facing Italy's new government

Salvini's League, the smaller, far-right Brothers of Italy party and former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi's centre-right Forza Italia party have all insisted the country return immediately to the polls for fresh elections.

A Quorum Youtrend poll published by SkyTG24 on Friday found the League still far outstrips the other parties despite a recent decline, bagging 32 percent of voter intentions, compared to 22 percent for the PD and 19 for the M5S. Some 32 percent of those surveyed said they trusted Salvini, compared to 26 percent for Di Maio.

Should the talks break down, Italy could hold an election at the beginning of November. 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.


Italy plans to stop ‘revolving door’ between judges and politicians

Italian lawmakers on Tuesday advanced a planned reform aimed at stopping the 'revolving door' between justice and government, as part of wider changes to the country's creaking judicial system.

Italy plans to stop 'revolving door' between judges and politicians

The proposed reform, which still has to be approved by the Italian Senate in the coming weeks, imposes significant limitations on the number of magistrates, prosecutors and judges looking to go into politics – a frequent move in Italy.

Under the submitted changes, a magistrate wishing to stand for election, whether national, regional or local, will not be able to do so in the region where they have worked over the previous three years.

At the end of their mandate, magistrates who have held elective positions will not be able to return to the judiciary – they will be moved to non-jurisdictional posts at, for example, the Court of Auditors or the Supreme Court of Cassation, according to local media reports.

Furthermore, magistrates who have applied for elective positions but have not been successful for at least three years will no longer be able to work in the region where they ran for office. 

The reform is part of a wider programme of changes to Italy’s tortuous judicial system. This is required by the European Commission to unlock billions of euros in the form of post-pandemic recovery funds.

Public perception of the independence of Italian courts and judges is among the worst in Europe, according to the EU’s justice scoreboard.