Lombardy begins trialling coronavirus immunity blood tests
Italy began conducting antibody tests in one northern region on Thursday, seeking information about coronavirus immunity to help guide authorities in ending the lockdown.
Lombardy, the region hardest-hit by the coronavirus crisis in Europe's worst-affected country, is hoping that data derived from the blood tests will help people in the prosperous industrial region return to work sooner.
READ ALSO:
Nearly 13,000 people have already died of the virus in Lombardy - more than half of Italy's total dead.
Although Germany has already started nationwide antibody tests, and countries such as Finland and Britain have announced plans to roll them out, many doubts remain about how reliable data derived from the tests will be.
Health authorities have said 20,000 tests would be performed every day in Lombardy. First to be tested are those in the worst-hit provinces: health workers, those under quarantine showing coronavirus symptoms and those the have been in contact with, as well as others with mild symptoms.
Authorities hope to roll out the tests across the region after April 29.
The head of Italy's National Health Council, Franco Locatelli, said last month that antibody tests would help authorities determine the spread of the coronavirus.
Data would also provide "very relevant information on herd immunity" which would useful in developing strategies to help restart the country, he said, such as who could be allowed to go back to work.
Photo: AFP
The kits, made by Italian biotech firm DiaSorin, look for the presence of antibodies in the blood. Such antibodies indicate that the person has been exposed to the virus, pointing to some level of immunity.
They differ from the more common swab tests, which test molecules from nasal secretions to determine whether a person currently has the virus.
Lombardy's swab testing has revealed that 24 percent of those tested have the virus.
READ ALSO:
Immunity to the virus is little understood and hopes about its efficacy possibly exaggerated.
Lacking data, virologists and epidemiologists must extrapolate information from past coronaviruses, such as the SARS outbreak in 2002-2003, to make predictions.
Experts believe at least 60 to 70 percent of a population would need to be immune to the virus in order to gradually wipe it out.
But recent studies, such as one conducted in March and April by France's Institut Pasteur, have found that so-called "herd immunity" was harder to attain than believed.
And it is not known for how long immunity to coronavirus lasts, meaning there is a risk those deemed "immune" may be re-infected and pass along the virus to others.
Milan, capital of the wealthy Lombardy region, is at a standstill with strict lockdown rules in place. Photo: AFP
"There's no guarantee that these antibodies protect from a new infection. We can only hope so for the moment. We'll know in the future," Guido Marinoni, president of Bergamo's surgical and dental association, told AFP on Thursday.
Marinoni, who organised local testing in the hard-hit province of Bergamo and plans to study results, also cautioned that a lack of antibodies might mean the disease was still its early stages and antibodies had not kicked in yet.
Even more risky, a person who has developed antibodies can still carry traces of the virus, and be contagious. Therefore, experts such as Locatelli say antibody tests should be accompanied by swab testing.
Immunologist Jean-Francois Delfraissy, who heads France's scientific council formed to fight coronavirus, said many doubts remain.
"We're currently asking the question whether someone who has had COVID-19... is as protected as we think," he said.
Comments
See Also
Lombardy, the region hardest-hit by the coronavirus crisis in Europe's worst-affected country, is hoping that data derived from the blood tests will help people in the prosperous industrial region return to work sooner.
READ ALSO:
Nearly 13,000 people have already died of the virus in Lombardy - more than half of Italy's total dead.
Although Germany has already started nationwide antibody tests, and countries such as Finland and Britain have announced plans to roll them out, many doubts remain about how reliable data derived from the tests will be.
Health authorities have said 20,000 tests would be performed every day in Lombardy. First to be tested are those in the worst-hit provinces: health workers, those under quarantine showing coronavirus symptoms and those the have been in contact with, as well as others with mild symptoms.
Authorities hope to roll out the tests across the region after April 29.
The head of Italy's National Health Council, Franco Locatelli, said last month that antibody tests would help authorities determine the spread of the coronavirus.
Data would also provide "very relevant information on herd immunity" which would useful in developing strategies to help restart the country, he said, such as who could be allowed to go back to work.
Photo: AFP
The kits, made by Italian biotech firm DiaSorin, look for the presence of antibodies in the blood. Such antibodies indicate that the person has been exposed to the virus, pointing to some level of immunity.
They differ from the more common swab tests, which test molecules from nasal secretions to determine whether a person currently has the virus.
Lombardy's swab testing has revealed that 24 percent of those tested have the virus.
READ ALSO:
Immunity to the virus is little understood and hopes about its efficacy possibly exaggerated.
Lacking data, virologists and epidemiologists must extrapolate information from past coronaviruses, such as the SARS outbreak in 2002-2003, to make predictions.
Experts believe at least 60 to 70 percent of a population would need to be immune to the virus in order to gradually wipe it out.
But recent studies, such as one conducted in March and April by France's Institut Pasteur, have found that so-called "herd immunity" was harder to attain than believed.
And it is not known for how long immunity to coronavirus lasts, meaning there is a risk those deemed "immune" may be re-infected and pass along the virus to others.
Milan, capital of the wealthy Lombardy region, is at a standstill with strict lockdown rules in place. Photo: AFP
"There's no guarantee that these antibodies protect from a new infection. We can only hope so for the moment. We'll know in the future," Guido Marinoni, president of Bergamo's surgical and dental association, told AFP on Thursday.
Marinoni, who organised local testing in the hard-hit province of Bergamo and plans to study results, also cautioned that a lack of antibodies might mean the disease was still its early stages and antibodies had not kicked in yet.
Even more risky, a person who has developed antibodies can still carry traces of the virus, and be contagious. Therefore, experts such as Locatelli say antibody tests should be accompanied by swab testing.
Immunologist Jean-Francois Delfraissy, who heads France's scientific council formed to fight coronavirus, said many doubts remain.
"We're currently asking the question whether someone who has had COVID-19... is as protected as we think," he said.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.