Italy’s constitutional court rejects right-to-die referendum
The Italian constitutional court blocked a referendum bid to decriminalise assisted suicide on Tuesday, judging that there were inadequate protections for the weakest.
Right-to-die advocates in Italy have been trying to force a referendum on the contentious issue in the largely Catholic country where opposition is strong, having gathered 750,000 signatures in August, well above the minimum required.
In announcing its decision, the court said in a press release the proposed referendum would not guarantee the constitutionally guaranteed "minimum protection of human life in general, particularly with reference to weak and vulnerable persons."
READ ALSO: Italian euthanasia petition big enough to force referendum
Under current Italian law, anyone helping another person commit suicide can be jailed for between five and 12 years.
In 2019, the court called on parliament to clarify its law on assisted suicide, saying euthanasia could be permissible for those with an incurable illness causing "intolerable" physical or psychological suffering, who were being kept alive by life support measures.
Those patients, however, must remain capable of making "free and informed decisions", it ruled.
Anyone who does not fall into this category has no current legal recourse to assisted suicide in the country.
Despite several high-profile cases in recent years, there remains strong opposition to assisted suicide in Italy, where the Catholic Church still holds major sway.
An Italian ethics committee in November allowed a tetraplegic man in his 40s to end his life through assisted dying, in the first approval of its kind.
READ ALSO: ‘Assisted suicide is not always a crime’: Italian court rules
Italy’s Constitutional Court made an exception for those facing an incurable illness causing “intolerable” physical or psychological suffering, where they are kept alive by life support treatments but remain capable of making “free and informed decisions”.
Following the rejected referendum, the heads of the Democratic Party and Five Star Movement - both within the coalition government of Prime Minister Mario Draghi - said it was now up to parliament to finally address the issue with a concrete law.
Comments
See Also
Right-to-die advocates in Italy have been trying to force a referendum on the contentious issue in the largely Catholic country where opposition is strong, having gathered 750,000 signatures in August, well above the minimum required.
In announcing its decision, the court said in a press release the proposed referendum would not guarantee the constitutionally guaranteed "minimum protection of human life in general, particularly with reference to weak and vulnerable persons."
READ ALSO: Italian euthanasia petition big enough to force referendum
Under current Italian law, anyone helping another person commit suicide can be jailed for between five and 12 years.
In 2019, the court called on parliament to clarify its law on assisted suicide, saying euthanasia could be permissible for those with an incurable illness causing "intolerable" physical or psychological suffering, who were being kept alive by life support measures.
Those patients, however, must remain capable of making "free and informed decisions", it ruled.
Anyone who does not fall into this category has no current legal recourse to assisted suicide in the country.
Despite several high-profile cases in recent years, there remains strong opposition to assisted suicide in Italy, where the Catholic Church still holds major sway.
An Italian ethics committee in November allowed a tetraplegic man in his 40s to end his life through assisted dying, in the first approval of its kind.
READ ALSO: ‘Assisted suicide is not always a crime’: Italian court rules
Italy’s Constitutional Court made an exception for those facing an incurable illness causing “intolerable” physical or psychological suffering, where they are kept alive by life support treatments but remain capable of making “free and informed decisions”.
Following the rejected referendum, the heads of the Democratic Party and Five Star Movement - both within the coalition government of Prime Minister Mario Draghi - said it was now up to parliament to finally address the issue with a concrete law.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.